A Cut Above Food Truck
Many an Olympic gymnast: TEEN. Boogie Nights: Naive young man stumbles into a career which requires him to have lots of sex with attractive young women. Film remake that tries to prove all unmarried. The whole picture is like a speeding train on which events get more gripping as it speeds along. While hardly anything leaves Sarris more bored and irritated than a stylistic tour de force, a cinematic event that exempts itself from the continuous adjustments and by-play of a thoroughly personal relationship, whether of characters to each other, of actors to a script, or of a director toward his actors. Madeleine West as Mrs. Stapleton.
The year was 1944, the journal The Nation, and the critic James Agee but Auden's letter to the editor sums up much of the love-hate relationship felt by most readers of film criticism ever since. Rolling Into Christmas. Barbie Presents Thumbelina: A girl convinces her parents not to work their hardest at their jobs. Canby is never wounded by a film, never angered, never elated, never transported. Film remake that tries to prove all unmarried men are created equal. Magic charm: AMULET. When I Think of Christmas. Even when he is not explicitly reducing films, events, and characters to "types, " "sorts, " and "kinds" as he does here, Canby's fundamental operating premise is that the purpose of a film is to present recognizable types, sorts, and kinds of experiences and characters (if it is not simply an escapist/fantasy movie, whose purpose is to leave intact and unsullied our repertory of types, sorts, and kinds).

But Canby's rhetoric and his saltatory form of argument are not reserved merely for high-toned films. A man nearly ruins a happy marriage and defaces a priceless work of art. Confronted with such a description of his critical clout, Canby vehemently denies it. Hilarity Ensues over misunderstandings over their intentions. The ruse is assisted by an illegal alien named after a man who was crucified (no, not that one). Even though he is more or less playing the straight man this time around, he still clearly recognizes a juicy story when he sees it (as he did with his previous collaboration with the Spierigs, the better-than-average vampire saga "Daybreakers") and gives real life to a character that could have easily blended into the woodwork in other hands. It is well to remember that this is an aggressively political, even polemical film, because Gilliatt's repetitions and variations on the theme of "hecticness, " the "non-stop breeziness" of her own analysis (like Kael's in so many of her reviews), succeed in turning it into a sort of still life. The films of Lumet, Lean, Pakula, Malle, Allen, and Mazursky are almost always as eminently reasonable, sanely "humanistic" (in Canby's limiting sense of the term), and socially melioristic as Canby's own sense of life. Barbie: Princess Charm School: Girls wrongly accused of theft clear their name by actually breaking in somewhere. Barbie and the Secret Door: A little girl almost takes over a nation. They are but an admission of Canby's unwillingness (or inability) to sustain a coherent, continued analysis for even the length of his column. It is not as thickly stocked with outrageous moments as Animal House, yet it is far easier to take to take than Where the Buffalo Roam. Kirk Franklin's The Night Before Christmas. Film remake that tries to prove all unmarried men. All rights reserved.

It is crucial to take in the double-edged quality of these modifiers, which, in case we don't get the point, is explained in the final sentence of The Godfather review, when Canby sums up the film as "one of the most brutal and moving [signs of shilly-shallying already creep in with this doublet] chronicles of American life ever designed [and watch this final twist] within the limits of popular entertainment. " More hackneyed: CORNIER. Battle Royale: A Japanese High School class has to fight to the death, or their heads will explode. The Times has a near-monopoly on the attention of a certain kind of upscale reader. All their lives improve as a result. He completely deflects the attack by treating the film as a camp parody of earlier Hollywood movies: This second film by Paul Morrissey is a relentless send-up of attitudes and gestures shanghaied from Hollywood's glamorous nineteen-thirties and forties. There are significant practical and theoretical problems with Sarris' position, and Kael masterfully pointed some of them out to him in their debate, but their differences over auteurism are really beside the point. A Bug's Life: After a guy accidentally pisses off the local biker gang, he hires a circus troupe to fight them off. A film becomes a succession of energetic dispersions, eccentricities, and excitements that conventional thematic and metaphoric glosses only gloss over. 'Should I get it out? ' One might defend Canby's insistent attention to a film's "handsomeness" and "buoyancy" as just another sign of a generosity toward mediocre pictures, or as a polite attempt to put the cheeriest face on his responses to mediocre work, if it weren't for the fact that these terms are not reserved for inoffensively bad movies. They borrowed jump cuts, wrote in the present tense (as if reporting a movie's plot) and described the surface of things as neutrally as a camera recording people and objects in its view.

Just when one needs a careful description or discrimination, Sarris will ground his review in the vague adjectives: a scene or a character is "warm, " "sincere, " "Iyrical, " or "convincing. " Not only does she pull off her performance brilliantly throughout—there is not one moment in which she is anything less that utterly convincing and believable—I would go so far as to put her work here up against any of the current front-runners for the Best Actress Oscar. All Schickel can muster up in his reviews is his own disappointment and weariness with his weekly task. Miss Hawn, even when she must look sort of wilted, like the figure on the top of a week-old wedding cake, is totally charming as the bemused suburban princess who forsakes a house with a live-in maid, her membership in the country club, and her role as man's best friend to find life's meaning in the service. Period of inactivity: CALM. Batman (1989): An orphan battles a clown. In the process, he turns the strange and elusive into the banal, as he turns Wanda into what he patronizingly calls a "conventional first feature": [Wanda] is a rather dumb young woman in the Pennsylvania coal country who, when we meet her, is drifting out of a marriage to a factory worker she couldn't care less about, and at the very end, is sitting, rather numb and baffled, in a road house, with strangers, drinking a glass of beer and holding a wet cigarette.